**Kylebooker Short Hackles – Fly Tying Materials – Black Hackles, Extra Small: A Detailed Review on Value for Money**
For fly-tying enthusiasts, selecting the right materials is crucial to creating effective and durable flies. One product that has garnered attention in recent years is the **Kylebooker Short Hackles** in **Extra Small Black Hackles**. Designed for precision and versatility, these hackles are marketed as a budget-friendly option for fly tiers. But how do they truly perform in terms of quality, usability, and overall value? Let’s dive into a comprehensive review.
### **Quality and Durability**
The first aspect to consider is the **quality of the feathers**. Kylebooker’s Extra Small Black Hackles are sourced from rooster necks, a traditional choice for dry fly and nymph tying. The feathers exhibit a **consistent texture and stiffness**, which is essential for achieving the desired buoyancy and movement in the water. Unlike some cheaper alternatives, these hackles do not fray easily when handled or wrapped around the hook.
However, compared to premium brands like Whiting or Metz, the **stem strength** is slightly weaker. While this isn’t a dealbreaker for occasional tiers, professionals might notice the difference when tying smaller patterns (size 18 and below). That said, for the price point, the durability is commendable.
### **Usability and Versatility**
One of the standout features of the Kylebooker Short Hackles is their **size consistency**. The “Extra Small” classification is accurate, making them ideal for tying **midges, small nymphs, and delicate dry flies**. The **short hackle fibers** allow for better control when wrapping, reducing the need for excessive trimming.
Additionally, the **black coloration** is deep and uniform, which is excellent for imitating dark-bodied insects like midges or ants. Unlike some dyed hackles that fade after exposure to water, these retain their color well, even after multiple fishing trips.
### **Price and Value**
The most compelling argument for the Kylebooker Short Hackles is their **affordability**. While high-end hackles can cost upwards of $30 per neck, this product offers a **cost-effective alternative** without sacrificing too much in quality. For beginners or intermediate tiers who don’t require ultra-premium materials, this is an excellent choice.
That said, if you’re tying flies for competitive fishing or selling them commercially, investing in a higher-grade hackle might be worth the extra cost. But for **casual anglers and hobbyists**, the Kylebooker hackles provide **solid performance at a fraction of the price**.
### **Final Verdict: Is It Worth It?**
In summary, the **Kylebooker Short Hackles (Extra Small, Black)** offer **great value for money**. While they may not match the elite standards of premium brands, they are more than sufficient for most fly-tying needs. Their **consistent size, decent durability, and affordability** make them a smart choice for anglers looking to stock up on materials without breaking the bank.
**Rating: 4/5**
✔ **Pros:** Affordable, good color retention, suitable for small flies
✖ **Cons:** Slightly weaker stems compared to premium brands
If you’re a **budget-conscious fly tier** or just starting out, this product is definitely worth considering. Happy tying and tight lines!